3.1 KiB
Battery discharge curves
I wanted to buy some Sony VTC6 batteries, and I was wary of fakes, so I wrote a battery discharge calculator with an associated hardware component (just a simple current and voltage sensor). I then took some measurements of my known-good batteries, and the new ones I bought.
The methodology was the following: I connected the battery to the sensor, and the sensor to a configurable load. I set the load to draw a certain amount of amps until it reached a cutoff voltage, and then to stop. I then plotted mAh drawn versus voltage, as well as amps drawn.
The batteries I connected were in various states of use, and various configurations (for various reasons, I couldn't test single cells). The configuration, state of the battery and provenance are mentioned below.
Here are the graphs:
Genuine Sony VTC6
This is a genuine (as far as I can tell) Sony VTC6, fairly used in high amp draw situations (I use it in my plane), in a 3S configuration:
You can see that it output around 2600 mAh before I stopped it at 3V, which is quite good.
Here's a brand new genuine VTC6, again in a 3S configuration:
This time I ran it all the way down to 2.8, and you can see it output the full 3000 mAh.
Fake Sony VTC6
This is a pretty blatantly fake "Sony VTC6", brand new, in a 2S configuration:
The performance falls off a cliff after around 3.6V, and it only outputs 1600 mAh before it dies completely.
Trying to draw 6-7A is even more spectacular (and it gets very hot to the touch):
Notice the huge voltage sag right as the load starts drawing.
Reclaimed NKON VTC-6
I bought some reclaimed Sony VTC-6 from NKON.nl, and I tested them here, in a 2S configuration at 1.5A.
They seem to be very genuine:
Not only are they genuine, but if we compare with the graph of the brand new VTC-6 above, we see that the reclaimed NKON batteries have had zero (or very few) cycles, as they gave the same Ah at 3.3V/cell as the new ones.
If you need it, here is the raw Assault and Battery results CSV for this battery.
White CNHL 4S 4000 mAh
This is a white CNHL 4S 4000 mAh LiPo battery, slightly used:
You can see that it's pretty decent, outputting nearly all of its nominal mAh, decently linearly, with a slightly faster drop after 3.7 V.
Last updated on December 19, 2022. For any questions/feedback, email me at hi@stavros.io.